Porter Street BBQ of Eureka Eureka
Porter Street BBQ of Eureka Logo

Porter Street BBQ of Eureka

4.41188 reviews

Porter Street BBQ of Eureka is a gem located right on Broadway St. This restaurant specializes in BBQ, offering a relaxed atmosphere for diners. The menu features local specialties that are sure to captivate taste buds. It comfortably accommodates families and solo diners alike.

The ambiance is casual and friendly. It draws in a mix of students, tourists, and locals. Its BBQ offerings, like the tri-tip and pastrami sandwiches, are crowd favorites. The quick service and generous portions mean it’s perfect for lunch or a casual dinner with friends or family. Don't miss the chance to enjoy outdoor cooking flavors right here.

With both dine-in and takeout options, there’s something irresistible about the smoky aroma that fills the air. It sets the scene for a delicious meal. From the very first bite of that tender beef rib to the last spoonful of chowder soup, Porter Street BBQ provides an experience that sticks to the heart.

About

Porter Street BBQ has become an iconic spot in Eureka since its inception. Situated at 605 Broadway St, it has carved a niche in the community with its unique approach to BBQ. The restaurant actively engages with local suppliers, ensuring fresh and quality ingredients for their dishes.

The atmosphere here is inviting. It encourages camaraderie among patrons. The story of this establishment revolves around not just food, but connections. Regulars treasure the people they meet here, and newbies quickly understand why it is cherished by many.

Guests often rave about the outdoor cooking method. Watching food prepared on a custom pit adds a special touch to the dining experience. The restaurant celebrates local cuisine, giving people a taste of Eureka's vibrant food culture. A visit is like reconnecting with the soul of the town.

Get in Touch

605 Broadway St, Eureka, CA 95501, United States

Opening Hours

  • Monday 10:30-20:00
  • Tuesday 10:30-20:00
  • Wednesday 10:30-20:00
  • Thursday 10:30-20:00
  • Friday 10:30-20:00
  • Saturday 10:30-20:00
  • Sunday Closed

Where to Visit

Get Directions

Customer Reviews

"The store are busy and the staffs are very friendly and helpful. Beef rib and tri beef were excellent. The condiments are very good for the meal. Chowder soup also works great"

- 5679 W.

"I just don't think this BBQ was for me. The staff are amazing. Helpful and very nice. I had the pork ribs and 1 beef rib. The macaroni salad was okay. The beef and pork ribs had great flavor. However, they may have been over seasoned. The sauce that they had to dip was very good. Both of them were extremely chewy. My jaw got a workout."

- Trying C.

"Haven't come here for about 10 years. So happy I came here with my family today. Used to come here all the time as a teen. My god have I missed the tri tip sandwiches are amazing. However the BBQ sauce has changed. It used to be addictive for me. Still love this place though."

- Nicole R.

"Drove through recently and tried this place. Ordered the heart attack sandwich, it was so good. If it wasn't closing time I would have ordered another. Recommend this to my friend. His family loved it. His daughter doesn't eat meat much, and she really loved the ribs. They are bringing me a sandwich home lol. Tri tip, ribs, and bbq sauce are awesome. Will drive through to try again."

- Lance W.

"Awesome!! Like always. They have the best sandwiches I have found in this county so far and I've been here all my life. You have to try them atleast once. They're a little pricey, but so worth every penny."

- Tammy L.

"Great welcome as soon as we walked in the door . lots of options on the menu. I had the sampler platter tri-tip beef and pork ribs with a chicken thigh a side of potato salad and a cup of chili. Everything was great . My wife ordered the pastrami sandwich also fantastic. They cook everything outside on a custom pit . While we were leaving we had the privilege of meeting the owner and shared the restaurant history with us "

- Rex G.

"I ordered my 1/2 lb burger medium and what they served me was a crispy critter. I didn't send it back because I don't like to waste food. I hope the staff is more careful going forward."

- Julian G.
Write a Review

Why Visit

There are a few reasons to drop by Porter Street BBQ. For starters, the BBQ is truly exceptional. The tri-tip sandwich has a devoted following. It's tender, flavorful, and simply a must-try. Many claim it’s one of the best they’ve had, and it frequently garners rave reviews from diners.

The friendly staff elevates the experience. They welcome customers with warm smiles. Their helpfulness shines through in everything they do, from recommending menu items to ensuring you feel at home. This personal touch creates memorable dining moments.

Porter Street BBQ is not just about eating; it's about enjoying a laid-back atmosphere. Patrons can enjoy meals while catching up with friends or simply soaking in the casual vibe. The restaurant has become a community hub, where stories and meals are shared.

Takeout and delivery options are available for those on the go. The menu has an impressive variety, catering to different cravings. Accompany your meal with a side of chili or potato salad. You won't regret it. Lastly, the accessible amenities support everyone, ensuring a comfortable dining experience.

Most Liked Things

The tri-tip sandwich receives rave reviews. Its rich flavor and generous portion truly stand out. The pulled pork is tender and juicy. Another favorite is the heart attack sandwich. Diners rave about its indulgent combination of flavors.

Chowder soup complements any meal and is very popular. The casual ambiance fosters connection, making meals enjoyable and memorable. Friendly staff always enhance the experience. You’ll feel welcomed and cared for.

Customers also appreciate the outdoor cooking atmosphere. The aroma from the BBQ pit tantalizes the senses. This adds an extra flavor dimension to the experience. Many locals cherish this spot, making it more than just a restaurant.

Most Disliked Things

Some diners find certain dishes may be over-seasoned for their taste. This can distract from the natural flavors of the meats offered. A few reviews mention that certain items can be a bit chewy, particularly the ribs.

Parking may be limited during peak hours. Although there are accessible parking options, you might have to be patient during busy times, especially on Saturdays.

The restaurant can get very busy, leading to longer wait times for food. It might be a good idea to visit during off-peak hours if you prefer a quieter dining experience. However, this bustling atmosphere is another aspect of its charm.

FAQ

What are the must-try dishes at Porter Street BBQ?

Porter Street BBQ offers a delicious tri-tip sandwich, beef ribs, and pulled pork. The homemade barbecue sauce enhances the flavors. For sides, try the coleslaw or potato salad.

Is there an option for takeout at Porter Street BBQ?

Yes, takeout is available. The restaurant provides convenient options for those on the go or dining at home.

Does Porter Street BBQ have any vegetarian options?

Currently, the menu mainly features meat-centric dishes. However, the large spring mixed salad can be an excellent choice for vegetarians.

Is parking available at Porter Street BBQ?

Yes, there is accessible parking available. Both street parking and designated lots provide ample space for guests.

What is the price range at Porter Street BBQ?

Prices range from $10 to $20, making it an affordable option. Average meal costs about $16.29, providing great value for tasty barbecue.